A recent decision by U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton has upheld new Arizona voting laws that mandate registered voters to provide proof of U.S. citizenship to ensure their votes are counted. These laws, which have been the subject of controversy and accusations of discrimination, were defended by Bolton, who stated that Arizona’s initiative to prevent voter fraud and restrict voting to eligible individuals does not constitute discrimination.
The judge highlighted the state’s vested interest in safeguarding its electoral processes against unauthorized voting, asserting that the benefits of these requirements outweigh any minor inconveniences voters might face in providing documentary proof of citizenship. However, Bolton did note an exception regarding a specific aspect of the laws. She pointed out that requiring voters to state their birthplace on registration forms contravenes the Civil Rights Act and a segment of the National Voter Registration Act, as it could lead to misconceptions about a person’s citizenship status based on their place of birth.
The ruling also addressed a measure calling for state election officials to verify voters’ registration details against government databases to confirm citizenship, directing officials to report any discrepancies to legal authorities. Despite acknowledging the rarity of non-citizen voting and fraud in Arizona, Bolton concluded that the new regulations could potentially deter non-citizens from attempting to register or vote.
This judgment followed testimonies presented during a bench trial in late 2023, which delved into Arizona’s historical challenges with voting discrimination, including literacy tests and voter roll purges that disproportionately impacted Native American and Latino communities. Nonetheless, Bolton determined these historical instances were not directly relevant to the present laws aimed at curtailing voter fraud, finding no evidence to suggest a legislative intent to suppress voter registrations.
The laws, enacted in the aftermath of the contentious 2020 presidential election, were signed by then-Gov. Doug Ducey, a Republican, who emphasized the importance of ensuring electoral integrity by validating every lawful vote and preventing illegal voting attempts. The enactment of these measures, passed along party lines, marks a significant moment in Arizona’s ongoing efforts to refine and secure its electoral processes.