New York City Council member Amanda Farías has come under fire for perceived hypocrisy following her recent comments on social media concerning a series of violent assaults against women in New York City. Farías, who previously called for “justice” in the case of Jordan Neely—a homeless man who died after being placed in a chokehold by subway passengers he threatened—raised questions about the lack of public outcry over recent attacks on women.
Farías’ critique came in response to a statement by the New York City Women’s Caucus, expressing deep concern over confirmed reports by the NYPD of widespread attacks on women. She questioned, “Where are the men calling this out?” on the social media platform X.
However, Farías’ call to action quickly attracted criticism, particularly from those who argue that the current political climate, influenced by figures like Farías herself, discourages citizens from intervening in violent situations. Critics point to the case of Daniel Penny, a Marine Corps veteran charged with manslaughter after subduing Neely, as an example of how individuals acting in defense can face severe legal repercussions.
Robby Starbuck, Christina Pushaw, Ryan Girdusky, and Mike Cernovich are among those who highlighted the contradiction in Farías’ stance, suggesting that her support for punitive action against Penny contradicts her call for intervention against assaults on women. They argue that such positions create an environment where people are fearful of assisting others due to potential backlash from authorities and the public.
Farías’ previous statements expressing outrage over Neely’s death and demanding justice have been cited as examples of her stance on such interventions. Critics maintain that this contributes to a broader reluctance among the public to act in situations of distress, fearing legal and social consequences.
The trial of Daniel Penny is set for October, with the case expected to highlight issues surrounding public safety, mental health, and the rights of individuals to protect themselves and others in threatening situations. Meanwhile, New York City continues to grapple with transit crime and concerns over public safety, with Governor Kathy Hochul deploying the National Guard and state troopers to assist in efforts to curb violence.
As the debate unfolds, Farías’ comments have ignited a conversation about the responsibilities of elected officials in shaping public perceptions of justice, safety, and individual action in the face of crime.