A study that has recently resurfaced, initially published by Emission Analytics in 2022, casts electric vehicles (EVs) in a new light, suggesting they might not be as environmentally friendly as previously thought. According to the research, EVs emit a significantly higher quantity of toxic particles, primarily due to tire and brake wear, compared to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles. This finding challenges the prevailing narrative of EVs as a purely green alternative.
The study, which garnered renewed attention following a Wall Street Journal op-ed, reveals that the particles released from the tires and brakes of EVs are 1,850 times greater than the emissions from the tailpipes of modern gasoline-powered cars. These cars are now equipped with efficient exhaust filters that minimize emissions. The heavier weight of EVs, often more than 30% heavier than their gasoline counterparts due to their batteries, exacerbates tire wear, leading to greater emissions of toxic particles.
Emission Analytics points out that most vehicle-related pollution today stems from tire wear. As vehicles, especially heavier ones like EVs, travel on roads, their tires gradually wear down. This process releases various harmful chemicals into the environment, which are derived from the synthetic rubber (a petroleum product) and other additives used in tire manufacturing.
For instance, popular EV models like Tesla’s Model Y and Ford’s F-150 Lightning, feature lithium-ion batteries that significantly contribute to the vehicle’s total weight, thereby increasing tire wear and, consequently, the emission of particulate pollution. This discovery raises questions about the environmental impact of EVs and the effectiveness of policies aimed at promoting their widespread adoption as a means to combat climate change.
The implications of these findings are profound, especially considering the ambitious goals set by the Biden administration, which aims to make two-thirds of new cars in America electric by 2032. The classification of EVs as “zero-emissions vehicles” is now under scrutiny, given their indirect contributions to environmental pollution.
Nick Molden, the founder and CEO of Emissions Analytics, highlights a crucial trade-off: while EVs contribute to a significant reduction in CO2 emissions, which is beneficial for combating climate change, they also increase particulate pollution, posing a risk to public health. Exposure to these particles can lead to severe health issues, including heart disease, asthma, and low birth weight.
To mitigate the environmental and health impacts of tire wear from EVs, Molden suggests the development and use of more sustainable materials for tires. This approach could help balance the benefits of EVs in reducing CO2 emissions with the need to minimize their adverse effects on air quality and public health.
As the debate over the environmental credentials of EVs continues, this study serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in transitioning to a more sustainable transportation future. It underscores the necessity for ongoing research, innovation, and policy-making that considers the full spectrum of environmental impacts associated with different vehicle technologies.