ABC News correspondent Matt Gutman drew fire from viewers and public figures after describing text messages sent by Tyler Robinson—the suspect accused of assassinating Charlie Kirk—as “very touching.” During a press conference, Gutman read selections from messages Robinson allegedly sent to his transgender partner shortly after the killing. In them, Robinson reportedly used affectionate language such as “my love” and expressed concern for his partner’s safety.
Many critics say Gutman’s portrayal was inappropriate given the gravity of the crime. Among those speaking out were former Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, conservative commentators, and other public figures who felt the coverage risked humanizing a suspect in a brutal attack. Some called for ABC News to take disciplinary action.
Gutman, meanwhile, emphasized the emotional contrast presented by the evidence: messages revealing love and tenderness alongside violent acts committed in front of a crowd, including children. He said the juxtaposition provided a more complicated picture of the accused. The segment remains a subject of debate over journalism ethics and the line between reporting facts and appearing empathetic toward individuals accused of serious crimes.