In a dramatic vote, Key West’s city commission decided 5–1 to terminate its partnership with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement under the 287(g) program—a move that places the city at odds with President Trump’s immigration enforcement agenda.
Commissioner Lissette Carey, the lone dissenting vote, expressed deep concern over the decision. Citing extensive research, Carey argued that maintaining cooperation with ICE was crucial for public safety and adherence to federal and state immigration mandates. She voiced her shock at being the sole commissioner to oppose the termination.
This decision has prompted stronger state scrutiny. Florida’s attorney general has warned the city that the vote may violate the state ban on sanctuary cities, cautioning that officials could face suspension or removal if compliance issues are not rectified swiftly.
Governor Trump has emphasized that local governments must enforce federal immigration laws or risk intervention. Key West, however, has defended its choice, calling on residents and civil society to support its stance on protecting asylum seekers and maintaining trust between immigrants and local authorities.
With this vote, Key West joins a growing number of municipalities challenging federal immigration policy—highlighting sharp divisions between local autonomy and national enforcement across Florida.